Clumsy Plot Devices and Romance
Wednesday, October 7, 2009Lately I’ve been coming across a lot of grumbling stomachs as a way to inject romance into a story non-romance story. A recent example is two characters are working together to solve a mystery, then suddenly someone’s stomach growls loudly because of hunger, so the two characters go for dinner, interact in a non-work related way and fall in love.
It can be challenging coming up with reasons your characters do something like fall in love, but, really, a grumbling stomach?
Romance is considered a lesser form of writing (and to be fair, there are some atrocious romances out there), but the best ones bring together two people in believable ways. Mainstream literary fiction on the other hand may be imaginative, poignant, beautifully written, and even award-winning, yet readers and critics turn a blind eye to an awkwardly executed romance. Although to be honest, I prefer a clumsy plot device to books that suddenly have two characters turn to one another halfway through the book and profess their love, without ever having taken the time to show us a hint of possible chemistry between them.
And don’t even get me started on embarrassing sex scenes that some authors throw in – embarrassing not because I don’t like to read about two characters having sex, but embarrassing because I wonder if the writer might qualify for the Literary Review Bad Sex Awards and not even realize it.
Not everyone can and should write erotica, but I think that clumsy plot devices as they relate to romance can be easily helped.
Here’s a helpful checklist to see if your romantic subplot needs help:
( ) Does the plotline look like it’s been cooked up by a teenager or even worse, a preteen? Unless your characters are that age group, come up with something else.
( ) Is it needlessly complicated? Do the characters really need reasons other than a general desire for one another’s company? If they’re adults, then no, they don’t.
( ) Does the story really need a romance?
If you’re set on including romance and sex in your story, then treat the scene the same way you do the rest of your craft, which means practice. There are a ton of free adult fiction websites that you can anonymously post short stories or even just vignettes. From there you can gauge reader reactions. And if this seems like too much work for a throwaway scene or two, then it might be best to leave it out of your story altogether.
Always be true to your story. But make sure that the story you tell is to the best of your ability, and if romance isn’t it, then you’re better off leaving it out. Your reader can be easily pulled out of your story by a clunky love scene, buy they won’t even notice if it isn’t there.
Posted: under Productive Behaviours to Spark and Enhance Creativity.
Tags: Advice, Critique, On Writing Comments (0)